When talking about this movie, people frequently bring up the fact that the message boils down to the fact that, in the end, it really does matter what you look like, and that the ugly guy won’t ever get the girl no matter how nice he is.

Well. Those people are wrong.

Think harder. There are three contenders for Esmeralda’s affections - Frollo, Quasimodo, and Phoebus. Frollo has zero affection for Esmeralda. No affection, no respect, no good feelings at all. All he feels is lust. And when he looks at her, all he sees are her faults (or what he believes are faults). He sees her a sexy gypsy who has spent her whole life in sin. And that causes him to feel lust. Because of this, he is incapable of seeing her good heart and truly decent soul. He sees a problem in need of fixing.

The audience wants Quasimodo to get the girl because he’s nice and she treats him well, and he deserves to catch a break for once in his life. And those things are all true. However. That line of thought essentially equates Esmeralda to his prize, to an object rather than a person. The problem with a Quasimodo-Esmeralda pairing is the exact opposite of Frollo. Frollo sees no good qualities in her, Quasimodo sees no bad qualities. He puts her on a pedestal and blinds himself to any mistakes she may make or flaws in her personality. He idolizes her in a way that is not healthy.

But Phoebus… Phoebus sits between the two: he sees her good, he sees her bad, and he can see the whole picture. He sees Esmeralda as she actually is - a person. She is not a sinful creature in need of reform and she is not a perfect specimen of humanity. Phoebus is the only one who can see that, and the only one who respects her as a person instead of a prize.

And that’s why the pretty guy gets the girl.

Disney Esmerelda Frollo Phoebus Quasimodo The Hunchback of Notre Dame Esmeralda

  1. pastrydoll reblogged this from never-been-sane
  2. writtentofreedom reblogged this from judeicialcourt
  3. myhonestimpression reblogged this from whiskey-lovin-twenty-nothings
  4. theb00kwasbetter reblogged this from chessgrins
  5. a-trans-battling-against-himself reblogged this from waaaaaytoogaytofunction
  6. faalst-sokink reblogged this from capaciousknight
  7. oblivionwriter reblogged this from soulofkeys
  8. under-dah-sea reblogged this from castiel-is-delightful
  9. capaciousknight reblogged this from littlemisshaleybug
  10. nigramulier reblogged this from hyperbunny94
  11. chessgrins reblogged this from yuuyamiartist
  12. judeicialcourt reblogged this from nostalgiaunicorn
  13. rumbellehasthephonebox reblogged this from gaurdian-of-dreamers
  14. brucewayneishot reblogged this from wander-lust07
  15. yulie1022 reblogged this from millennium-lily
  16. castiel-is-delightful reblogged this from iwasbornintothespoopy-moldedbyit
  17. indecisive-penguin reblogged this from gigacat
  18. ohthehypocrisy reblogged this from palfkcaj
  19. aibohp reblogged this from gigacat
  20. waaaaaytoogaytofunction reblogged this from incrediblyspooky
  21. axel-j reblogged this from hannahsawsbirds
  22. patchworkoven reblogged this from emtalist
  23. weeweeabootrash-senpai reblogged this from rainylotus
  24. falcon64 reblogged this from nostalgiaunicorn